Established cartoon material has been moderately successful.
"The Simpsons" and other Simpsons- related comic books
have done okay, but they fail to capture the kinetic manicness
of the TV show. Similarly, "Ren & Stimpy", "Beavis & Butthead"
and "Aladdin" were all moderate hits, but failed to capture the
necessary qualities of the characters' voices. All of these
examples are from the 90's, but a look at any of the cartoon
based comic books of the past reveals a more important
factor. The intrinsic problem is that when people lose interest
in the cartoon, cancellation of the comic is sure to follow. Only
such stalwarts as "Mickey Mouse", "Donald Duck" and "Archie"
can lay claim to lengthy runs.
Fantasty comics based on previously established material
have maintained a mediocre presence in the market. Marvel's
"Conan the Barbarian" lasted for 23 years. But the various
Conan spin-offs of the 1980's were pretty dismal. All of the
TSR property Dungeons and Dragons comics were short-lived.
Conversely, fantasy comics based on original material have
done quite well, particularly by independent companies. Dave
Sim's Cerebus (Aardvark-Vanaheim) is over two-thirds of the
way through its projected 25 year run. Wendy and Richard
Pini's Elfquest (WaRP Graphics) has been chugging along for
twenty years now. Most recently, Jeff Smith's Bone (Cartoon
Books, 1991- present) has made its mark in comic shops. I
would posit that original fantasy comics have garnered more
success as the authors actively promote their materials and
are more responsive to their fans.
How to Cartoon
The following resources, both online and print, are helpful for the cartoonist who wants to
learn how to improve his art or his chance of making a living from it.
Your Career In The Comics by Lee Nordling.
Anyone seriously interested in being a cartoonist MUST buy the book Your
Career in the Comics by Lee Nordling. It's about $8, and contains wealth of
information about the business issues cartoonists face when playing the
syndicating game. You can get it at some bookstores, or from Amazon.com
through the above link.
Duane Barnhart's Cartooning Basics : Creating the Characters by Duane Barnhart and Angie
Barnhart.
This useful guide with over 500 illustrations is an entertaining and humorous book filled
with easy to follow suggestions that assure that even beginners - young and old - can
produce successful cartoons. Duane is a professional cartoonist who has been
published in "the Saturday Evening Post", his own syndicated comic strip, and many
childrens' books. This book is based on Duane's teaching cartooning in schools and art
centers as an artist in residence. Charles M.Schulz, Creator of Peanuts, wrote the
foreword, and initial response indicates the book will become a standard reference in
cartooning and teaching.